- The Smarter Brain
- Posts
- Why Do Customers Pay More for Things They Could Get Cheaper?
Why Do Customers Pay More for Things They Could Get Cheaper?
The psychology of premium prices, brand trust, perceived value, status, convenience, and why “expensive” doesn't always mean “bad value”
Welcome to The Smarter Brain, a curation of thought-provoking ideas and actionable reads to help you build better habits and become more productive.
Happy reading - See you on Wednesday!
Cheers,
The Smarter Brain Team
Estimated Reading Time: 2 mins
3 Ideas for Better Habits
They Buy the Why
Simon Sinek is a leadership and marketing author known for his work on purpose, brand loyalty, and consumer motivation.
“People don’t buy what you do; they buy why you do it.”
Create the Customer
Peter Drucker was an influential management thinker whose work shaped modern ideas about strategy, management, and customer value.
“The purpose of business is to create a customer.”
Source: The Practice of Management
They Buy the Story
Seth Godin is an American author and entrepreneur known for his work on marketing, branding, and consumer behavior.
“People do not buy goods and services. They buy relations, stories and magic.”
Productivity Tools and Resources
Dyson's $500 Toothbrush May Be the Ultimate Pricing Power Test
The article uses Dyson's unusually expensive toothbrush to explore the difference between simply charging a premium and possessing genuine pricing power. The key question is whether customers will actually pay without needing discounts.
Pricing Power: How to Protect It in a Budget-Conscious Market
The article looks at how businesses can maintain pricing power when customers are becoming more price-conscious. It emphasizes credibility and communicating superior value rather than simply raising prices.
Compare Prices
ShopSavvy lets shoppers compare prices across retailers, making it useful for seeing the gap between a cheaper alternative and a premium product.
Price History
Keepa tracks Amazon product prices over time. It's useful for seeing whether a supposedly “premium” price is actually unusual or whether the product regularly sells at different prices.
What We're Reading
Marketing Brew - A business/marketing newsletter covering brands, advertising, consumer behavior, and the strategies companies use to influence purchasing decisions. It fits the topic because premium pricing is closely connected to how brands create and communicate value.
The State of Paid Newsletters - This is particularly relevant because beehiiv's 2026 research analyzed thousands of paid newsletters and found that pricing varies substantially by perceived value and category-not simply by audience size. Business newsletters had a median price of about $15/month, while investing newsletters reached $27/month.
Brain Food
Today I Learned: A study of 405 new automobile buyers found that brand experience influenced willingness to pay a price premium, both directly and through brand credibility and perceived uniqueness. (Source)
Science: A 2026 study examining limited-edition heritage products found that limited-quantity scarcity cues increased willingness to pay through increased perceived brand value. The effect was stronger when scarcity was combined with heritage cues. (Source)
Have a productive rest of your week,
The Smarter Brain Team
Resource Spotlight
Why Story Beats Price: Emotion, Identity, and the Things We’re Willing to Pay More For
Monthly dispatches rooted in consumer psychology, not spreadsheets-this one's about why we sometimes choose the product that feels more like us, even when a cheaper alternative does essentially the same job. Explore how stories, identity cues, social proof, and the way a product is framed can change what we're willing to pay.
The Pricing Iceberg: Why “Too Expensive” Is Really About Meaning
Monthly dispatches rooted in consumer psychology, not simple price tags-this one's about what customers are actually reacting to when they say something is “too expensive.” Explore how price is filtered through perceived value, fairness, quality signals, social meaning, trust, and identity before conscious reasoning even enters the picture.
The Psychology of Paying More: Anchoring, Bundling, and the Price of Convenience
Monthly dispatches rooted in behavioural pricing, not pricing theory in isolation-this one's about why customers can happily pay more for an option that isn't technically the cheapest. Using all-inclusive holidays as a case study, explore how anchoring, decoy pricing, bundling, prepayment, and flat-rate pricing can transform the way customers experience value.
(Everything in the section above is an ad, book yours here)
How would you rate this newsletter? |
Partner with The Smarter Brain and reach 8,000 professionals' inboxes. Contact us to learn more.
If you enjoy The Smarter Brain, we would really appreciate you spreading the word by sharing the sign up link to a colleague or friend. Thank you!
Collaborate with The Smarter Brain